Book Review: Verity

I can’t believe I just read that with my own two eyes.

When Lowen receives an offer to take over writing the bestselling series of Verity Crawford after an accident leaves her catatonic, it is an offer she can’t refuse. In desperate need of money, she moves into Verity’s house to begin studying her notes. What she doesn’t expect is the budding romance between her and Verity’s husband…or finding Verity’s autobiographical manuscript. As each twist of the manuscript leads her deeper into the mind of Verity, Lowen begins to wonder who exactly in the house she can trust. 

So I guess my new thing is comparing every domestic thriller I read to Gone Girl but, this really reminded me of gone girl toward the end. Once again, pretty unbelievable, but also very compelling. The characters were dark and twisty, untrustworthy, and larger than life. The flipping perspectives between Lowen and the manuscript felt a lot like flipping to Amy’s diary. The villain was diabolical, and for sure the main character. It left me questioning everything throughout the book, even after the ending. 

And yet, for the first time in the life of my blog, I’m not giving a book a rating. I genuinely don’t know how to with this one. Despite it being a page turner, I really wouldn’t say it was enjoyable. Now, I don’t think it was supposed to be enjoyable, so I have to say the writing style was successful. But you have to be okay with reading a certain amount of graphic violence in order to be a fan of this book, and I don’t fall into that category. 

The depictions of child abuse were downright horrifying. When I read reviews saying this was a book that was exceptionally creepy, I was super excited. I was hoping for some Rebecca or Coraline style fear-factor, where you don’t want to read without have daylight streaming through your windows. Something not necessarily paranormal, but that sets you on the edge of your seat. But that really wasn’t what I got. It wasn’t “creepy” in a horror sense, but creepy in a “wow this is really disturbing and uncomfortable to read how is it possible for someone to even write this” way. 

At the same time, I couldn’t put it down. It was like watching a car accident. I didn’t want to read it, but I also couldn’t look away. It was suspenseful, unlike anything I had read before, and brought up some interesting questions. Where is the boundary between reality and fiction, and is there ever a point where you cross a line in writing? At what point in trying to get into the mindset of a villain can you actually become the villain? CoHo definitely has a skill for drawing readers in. She writes absolutely gut-wrenching and heartbreaking stories. However I think the 14 year old me that appreciated her unpredictability and huge plot twists has grown up. I’m all for emotional books, but I can see this one being emotionally scarring. 

I get why this book found its audience, and that people appreciate the shock value. But I think, sadly, I’m moving on from CoHo books. 

happy reading (:

Pacing: medium
Intended audience: Adult
Content warnings: graphic child abuse, attempted murder, murder, drowning, car accident, death of a loved one, cancer, adultery

All graphics and animations on this site were designed by me. Click here to inquire about custom blog graphics or here to view my Etsy shop.

32 thoughts on “Book Review: Verity

  1. I read this last year and it was an uncomfortable read. After that, I felt I was done with CoHo but, a book club I’m in read Layla and while it was a little bit weird with questionable points, I didn’t walk away with the same feelings as with Verity.


  2. It was extremely creepy but I still kept reading and then stared into space for a good few minutes afterwards! Because wth did I just read!!? But it’s why I love COHO because her books vary in plot twists and story lines! I appreciated this story but probably won’t ever read it again lol call it being scarred !

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I just recently finished reading It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover and my god was I invested in that book.
    Verity sounds like a novel that I know I shouldn’t read, but I will end up reading. After reading your view, I want to read it even more. 🙈
    Great review by the way! 💕

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Uh, that sounds like something with a rather targetedc audience. I had similar feelings about Black Leopard Red Wolf, but that was a DNF for me because it really was too much to read in the end.

    I’m fine with creep in the Coraline sense, but some things really leave me with the question if that was really necessary. Could the story have worked without this? Most likely, yes. But then I think I’m just not the audience, you know.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. “Emotionally Scarring”
    Every time a book is described as Emotionally Scarring, I don’t know why but I just get drawn towards it. And then begins the emotional torture. I was happily living under a rock to not know about the existence of this book. Now I know I am going to read and get scarred… But these are the best scars


  6. After seeing this book all over TikTok I thought I might want to read it, but maybe I’ll try a different CoHo book first 😯 This review showed this book is def not my style!!!


  7. I had a hard time rating this book after I read it as well. In the end I decided that for a thriller it was pretty good. It is so far my one and only experience with Colleen Hoover. I hear your romances are epic. I know I have to get around to reading a few of those.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s