ARC Review! All of us Villains

Was it what I was expecting? No. Did it get me out of a months long reading slump? Yes. 

The town of Ilvernath has a secret—it is the last town on earth that has access to high magick. Magick that is awarded to one of seven families through a deadly curse. Every 20 years, each family must choose a champion to fight, with the winner being the only one to leave with their life and access to the high magick. The time has come again for the curse to claim it’s victims, but these champions bring about unexpected twists that could change the tournament forever. 

Wow, that was a ride! In the first chapters I was convinced that this would be nothing more than a younger feeling ripoff of the hunger games, but I was actually pleasantly surprised. Yes, the teens have to fight to the death still. But that’s about where the similarities end. There’s magic, there’s sabotage, there’s romance. I really couldn’t tell where things were going to end up in the end. 

The characters were…okay. They were all interesting enough, but some of the romantic plots felt forced. I don’t think all of them were necessary to the story, and functioned more as a label draw than anything. I did enjoy how different all of the contestants were—none of them felt like caricatures or stereotypes of Typical Teens. The perspective shifts weren’t too confusing, although for some reason I couldn’t keep Isobel and Briony straight for the life of me. 

My issue really came in with how it all fit together. You’re telling me in all of the years of this curse, none of the contestants have ever had a *complicated* relationship before? Somehow THIS is the only generation of, let me remind you, children that has second thoughts about murdering six people? I didn’t quite buy it. And as another reviewer pointed out, the title is pretty misleading. You can’t really call a bunch of kids who are cursed and all have tragic backstories and various degrees of trauma from said curse “Villains”. Not to mention most of them are actually pretty nice? 

The magic system/ tournament rules were a little complex but not too difficult to keep up with. The story definitely ended abruptly. It almost felt like someone just grabbed the manuscript and said “okay time to publish!” Rather than it being an intentional cliffhanger. 

Those issues aside, I did really enjoy the journey. It managed to get me out of a slump, was fast paced, and pretty entertaining. Overall would recommend if you like magic, twistiness, and romance. 

happy reading (:

Rating: 3.5/5
Pacing: fast
Intended audience: YA
Content warnings: murder, gore 

All graphics and animations on this site were designed by me. Click here to inquire about custom blog graphics or here to view my Etsy shop.

10 thoughts on “ARC Review! All of us Villains

  1. That sounds VERY SIMILAR to An Unkindness of Magicians by Kat Howard, which is a fantastic read if you haven’t checked it out before. Same concept — there’s a ‘game’ or ‘sacrifice’ to protect magic, and people compete to see who wins.


  2. The ending really ticked me off with this one because it wasn’t labeled a book 1 on any retail sites. I gave it 3 stars too and will give the series another try when all the books are out. Great review!


  3. Hmm … Like the prospect of a fast-paced read. But the characters / relationships don’t sound all that great. I might have to rethink this one …


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s